Get Answers →
From All-or-Nothing to Consistency: Embolden Perimenopause

Flourish Series

From All-or-Nothing to Consistency: Embolden Perimenopause

Why your perfectionism is sabotaging your progress and how to build sustainable habits that actually stick during perimenopause.

Monday: "This time I'm doing everything perfectly..." Thursday: Exhausted, eating chips for dinner, convinced you're a failure. If you're nodding your head during perimenopause, welcome to the all-or-nothing club.

By Catharine Adams Published November 21, 2023 10 min read
From All-or-Nothing to Consistency: Embolden Perimenopause - Woman practicing mindful habits

It's standing room only in here, especially during perimenopause when our brains are already juggling hormonal chaos, and perfectionism feels like the only way to regain control.

Why Perimenopause Makes Perfectionism Worse

The Perfect Storm of Perimenopause and All-or-Nothing Thinking

Research shows that hormonal fluctuations during perimenopause can:

  • Increase anxiety - making us crave control through rigid rules during perimenopause
  • Affect executive function - harder to maintain complex routines in perimenopause
  • Disrupt emotional regulation - bigger crashes when we "fail" during perimenopause
  • Impact self-compassion - harsher inner critic in perimenopause

Add life stress (aging parents, teenage kids, career pressures, economic uncertainty) and perfectionism becomes our misguided coping mechanism during perimenopause.

"From all-or-nothing to consistency during perimenopause isn't about high standards. It's about fear. Fear of not being enough, especially when your body feels out of control."

The All-or-Nothing Trap in Perimenopause

Here's what happens in the perfectionist cycle during perimenopause:

  1. The Fantasy Phase: You create an impossible plan requiring superhuman discipline during perimenopause.
  2. The Honeymoon: Day 1-3 feel amazing (hello, dopamine!) even in perimenopause.
  3. The Reality Check: Life happens - a bad night's sleep, a hot flash, a stressful day during perimenopause.
  4. The Crash: One "slip" during perimenopause becomes complete abandonment.
  5. The Shame Spiral: You blame yourself during perimenopause, not the impossible system.

Rinse and repeat during perimenopause, each time eroding your self-trust a little more.


The Consistency Shift: Your New Operating System for Perimenopause

Shift 1: Progress Over Perfection in Perimenopause

FROM: "I must do everything perfectly during perimenopause or I've failed"
TO: "Something is always better than nothing during perimenopause"

In practice during perimenopause: Can't do your 45-minute workout? Do 10 minutes. Can't meal prep Sunday during perimenopause? Boil some eggs Tuesday night.

Shift 2: Flexible Standards for Perimenopause

FROM: "There's only one right way during perimenopause"
TO: "Good enough is good enough during perimenopause"

In practice during perimenopause: Create A, B, and C versions of your habits. A is ideal, B is modified, C is bare minimum. All count during perimenopause.

Shift 3: Self-Compassion During Perimenopause

FROM: "I'm so lazy/weak/undisciplined during perimenopause"
TO: "I'm human navigating perimenopause, a challenging phase"

In practice during perimenopause: Talk to yourself like you'd talk to your best friend. Would you call her a failure for missing a workout during a hot flash in perimenopause?


Building Your Consistency Practice During Perimenopause

The 2-Minute Baseline Method for Perimenopause

Choose ONE habit during perimenopause. Make it so small it's impossible to fail:

  • Exercise during perimenopause: Put on workout clothes (that's it).
  • Nutrition during perimenopause: Add one vegetable to one meal.
  • Mindfulness during perimenopause: Three deep breaths.
  • Sleep during perimenopause: Phone off 5 minutes before usual.

Do this for two weeks during perimenopause. Then, and only then, expand slightly. Success builds on success during perimenopause.

Why This Works (Especially During Perimenopause)

During perimenopause, your capacity varies daily. Some days you're superwoman during perimenopause, others you're barely functioning. A flexible, compassionate approach honors this reality of perimenopause.

The Science of Small Wins During Perimenopause

Research on habit formation during perimenopause shows:

  • Consistency matters more than intensity during perimenopause.
  • Small successes build self-efficacy during perimenopause.
  • Flexible goals improve long-term adherence during perimenopause.
  • Self-compassion increases motivation during perimenopause (contrary to popular belief).

Your Permission Slip for Real Life During Perimenopause

You have permission during perimenopause to:

  • Start over 100 times during perimenopause (it's not failure, it's data).
  • Modify everything based on how you feel during perimenopause.
  • Count tiny wins as real wins during perimenopause.
  • Rest without earning it during perimenopause.
  • Be inconsistently consistent during perimenopause.

The goal during perimenopause isn't to be perfect. It's to keep showing up, in whatever capacity you can, more often than not during perimenopause.

"From all-or-nothing to consistency during perimenopause: The woman who does something small 5 days a week beats the woman who does everything perfectly for 3 days then quits. Every. Single. Time."

Start where you are during perimenopause. Use what you have. Do what you can. And please, for the love of your sanity during perimenopause, let that be enough. Because it is.

For more support navigating perimenopause with self-compassion, explore our evidence-based self-care strategies for perimenopause.

"Perimenopause isn't your decline—it's your awakening. Let's navigate it together with science, strategy, and fierce love."

Catharine Adams, Certified Perimenopause Coach

Catharine Adams

Certified Menopause Coach Specialist • NASM-CNC • NASM-CPT • PN Level 1 • GGS-1 • Level 2 Mindset Coaching Certified • NASM-Weightloss Specialist

Certified Menopause Coaching Specialist & Perimenopause Navigator. Founder of The Meno Collective, helping women chart their course through midlife transitions with evidence-based guidance and compassionate support. She also provides personalised 1-on-1 coaching through Macros Inc.

Curious About Your Perimenopause Patterns? Take the Free Quiz

As a coach, I created this 3-minute tool to help women like you gain educational clarity on symptoms like 2 a.m. wake-ups. It identifies possible stages and hormone-related patterns, delivering general next steps to your inbox—100% private and evidence-informed.

Take the Quiz Now →

✓ Explore your stage | ✓ Understand common patterns | ✓ Get educational insights | Always consult your healthcare provider

Pin It on Pinterest